Breakenridge: Fed's financial assertion nudges CPP towards extra investments in Canada

One of many strongest arguments in favour of the CPP is simply how a lot success has been borne of its technique of pursuing the best return

Article content material

Within the notorious interrogation scene between Joker and Batman within the movie The Darkish Knight, there’s a memorable line because the villain reacts incredulously to an accusation that he needs demise upon the hero. “I don’t wish to kill you,” he declares. “What would I do with out you?”

To not indicate that there are essentially heroes and villains in Canadian politics, however there are definitely examples of symbiotic relationships between arch-rivals (even when the contributors are far much less candid about it). Working example: Justin Trudeau and Danielle Smith.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Article content material

For as a lot as Smith and the UCP would welcome the Liberals’ demise, they know deep down of their hearts that they’d even be dropping a political asset. Conservative Alberta premiers have lengthy benefitted from having a Liberal foil in Ottawa and that’s very true when that Liberal prime minister is as deeply unpopular as this one.

We noticed earlier this yr how the awkward rollout of the “Simply Transition” proved to be a political present to the UCP simply as they have been heading into an election marketing campaign. And now because the UCP’s push for leaving the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) appears to be faltering, it’s Trudeau to the rescue as soon as once more.

Not like the campaigns towards varied different federal insurance policies, it’s confirmed rather more tough to hyperlink the CPP to Trudeau. Albertans might not belief Trudeau, however they perceive that he’s not the one making funding choices for the CPP. Or, he shouldn’t be.

Enter final week’s Fall Financial Assertion. Misplaced amid the protection of the appreciable federal deficit and the assorted spending bulletins was a curious assertion of intent with regard to the CPP.

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

Regardless of earlier assurances from Ottawa that the CPP is and at all times will probably be free from political interference, the federal government appears to have determined that, nicely, possibly just a little interference isn’t so dangerous in spite of everything.

The financial assertion proposes to tug the CPP away from its present mandate of prioritizing one of the best return on its investments. As a substitute, the federal government now hopes to nudge the CPP towards making extra investments in Canada.

If there are wonderful funding alternatives available in Canada, then the CPP Funding Board would hardly want route from the federal authorities. If the federal government is just intending to extend Canada’s funding attractiveness, then there’s no purpose to hyperlink that particularly to pension funds.

It’s more likely that this federal involvement would have a heavy political bent to it, with these “funding alternatives” conveniently lining up with pet tasks, favoured industries, and strategically worthwhile areas.

Associated Tales

Commercial 4

Article content material

This needs to be of concern to all Canadians, not simply Albertans. One of many strongest arguments in favour of the CPP is simply how a lot success has been borne of its technique of pursuing the best return.

But when that’s now not going to be the technique, then Albertans may begin to suppose otherwise about this complete concern. There’s an comprehensible attachment to the thought of an impartial CPP with a sterling funding observe report. Conversely, there’s certain to be a substantial quantity of unease with the thought of CPP property turning into some form of political slush fund.

It’s very a lot on model that this prime minister would support the forces in Alberta that want to go away the CPP whereas on the identical time making it identified that he doesn’t want to see Alberta go away.

Thoughts you, the premier herself has mused about her authorities having a say within the investments of an Alberta Pension Plan, so the inevitable assaults on the brand new federal coverage is perhaps coated in some hypocrisy.

The prime minister certainly is aware of the stakes of Alberta exiting the CPP. Why they might select now to think about meddling with the CPP is really baffling. It’s extraordinarily unlikely that this was meant as a lifeline to the UCP’s floundering efforts, however that may nearly certainly be the tip outcome.

“Afternoons with Rob Breakenridge” airs weekdays 12:30-3 p.m. on QR Calgary

[email protected]

X: @RobBreakenridge

Article content material

Varcoe: 'Indeniable': Head of CPP Investments tells Calgary viewers that nationwide pension is protected, safe

In his speech, John Graham talked concerning the deserves of the nationwide pension mannequin ‘and why it’s one thing Albertans mustn’t wish to lose’

Get the most recent from Chris Varcoe, Calgary Herald straight to your inbox

Article content material

Discuss a $334-billion elephant within the room.

The pinnacle of the Canada Pension Plan Funding Board stopped within the province on Tuesday, talking to a few hundred enterprise leaders at a Calgary Chamber of Commerce luncheon, addressing the board’s third annual Alberta Power & Progress Discussion board.

Article content material

Whereas there was dialogue concerning the CPP’s $6-billion price of investments in Canada’s oil and fuel trade, the speech by CPP Investments chief govt John Graham got here smack dab in the course of a nationwide firestorm across the Alberta authorities’s pitch to probably withdraw from the nationwide pension plan.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Graham by no means talked about the Alberta authorities’s controversial ambition to carry a referendum on the province organising its personal plan.

But, he mentioned a lot.

The handle was delicate and made its factors “with out going nuclear,” as one one who attended the luncheon later quipped.

In his speech, Graham talked concerning the deserves of the nationwide pension mannequin “and why it’s one thing Albertans mustn’t wish to lose.”

He famous the CPP fund was price $576 billion by the tip of September, with a 10-year annualized web return of 9.6 per cent.

“In a world of fixed uncertainty, Albertans want to guard their monetary future. And entry to the CPP is a method Canadians residing in Alberta can defend themselves towards an unpredictable economic system,” Graham mentioned.

“The enterprise and the general public coverage case to stick with a longtime world funding fund, with a confirmed monitor file of funding efficiency, is indeniable.”

Graham additionally touted the advantages of being in a big pension plan and the portability of the CPP, which permits Canadians to take their pensions with them in the event that they transfer.

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

“The CPP is protected, the CPP is safe, it’s sturdy and it’s overseen by an impartial arm’s-length extremely certified funding professionals,” he added.

John Graham, president and CEO of CPP Investments, in Calgary
John Graham, president and CEO of CPP Investments, speaks throughout a Calgary Chamber of Commerce luncheon on the Westin Resort on Tuesday, November 14, 2023. Gavin Younger/Postmedia

Nonetheless, Premier Danielle Smith’s authorities has been unconvinced by such arguments prior to now.

As a substitute, it’s promoted the deserves of changing CPP with an Alberta pension plan, saying it might lower your expenses or enhance advantages, igniting a fierce debate within the province and throughout the nation.

A report for the UCP authorities by consultancy LifeWorks asserts that Albertans are entitled to 53 per cent of the bottom belongings of the CPP — or $334 billion — if the province decides to withdraw, though many specialists hotly dispute that notion.

The report contends that if Alberta acquired that sum, it might result in an estimated $5 billion in collective financial savings for a provincewide plan in its first yr.

Alberta makes up about 12 per cent of Canada’s whole inhabitants.

Officers with CPP Investments have beforehand mentioned the LifeWorks numbers don’t add up. College of Calgary economist Trevor Tombe, who not too long ago launched a paper on the difficulty, has estimated Alberta’s probably quantity round $120 billion, or 20 per cent of CPP belongings.

Commercial 4

Article content material

Alberta Finance Minister Nate Horner, who will communicate to the Calgary chamber on Friday, launched a quick assertion Tuesday, saying the province welcomes a “significant and good-faith dialog across the potential creation of an Alberta pension plan.”

The province has pressed the federal authorities to provide you with its personal determine on its share of the funds.

After a gathering of Canada’s finance ministers this month, Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland requested the Workplace of the Chief Actuary to estimate how a lot Alberta can be entitled to if it leaves, based mostly on a “affordable interpretation of the provisions within the CPP laws.”

In the meantime, a number of premiers and provincial finance ministers, together with federal Conservative Chief Pierre Poilievre, have both raised concern concerning the impact of Alberta’s potential exit or referred to as on the province to remain within the CPP.

It’s additionally left enterprise teams and leaders deeply uneasy.

Associated Tales

Commercial 5

Article content material

Calgary Chamber of Commerce CEO Deborah Yedlin mentioned enterprise operators are involved concerning the uncertainty of leaving the CPP, the portability of an Alberta plan and the way it would possibly have an effect on labour attraction.

“We respect the federal government’s place to look at this as an possibility. However when you consider it from the knowledge and uncertainty perspective, it’s one thing that we proceed to be centered on,” Yedlin advised reporters.

“The fact is, there’s no mulligan.”

George Brookman, chair of WCD Inc., attended Tuesday’s luncheon and mentioned he wish to see CPP Investments, the federal Crown company that manages the fund, enhance its funding within the oil and fuel sector within the province.

But, he stays involved concerning the concept of the province leaving the nationwide pension plan.

“It simply sounds increasingly more like Brexit to me, and that simply turns me off,” mentioned Brookman. “I’m simply not satisfied.”

Deborah Yedlin
Deborah Yedlin, Calgary Chamber of Commerce CEO, speaks throughout a Calgary Chamber of Commerce luncheon on the Westin Resort on Tuesday, November 14, 2023. Gavin Younger/Postmedia

The province launched the Alberta Pension Safety Act earlier this month, which might require a majority of individuals casting a poll in a referendum to vote in favour of a provincial plan earlier than it moved to withdraw belongings from the CPP.

Commercial 6

Article content material

Mount Royal College political scientist Duane Bratt mentioned the Smith authorities has tried to border the pension battle as a wrestle between Alberta and Ottawa, however with different provincial leaders and Poilievre weighing into the fracas, “that is the Alberta authorities versus the remainder of the nation.”

The province has been unable to persuade most of the people or enterprise leaders on the deserves of Alberta’s plan thus far.

“The federal government sees no threat, however the enterprise group does,” mentioned Bratt.

“They haven’t been in a position to sway them.”

Chris Varcoe is a Calgary Herald columnist.

[email protected]

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a vigorous however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. Now we have enabled e mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e mail in the event you obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you observe or if a consumer you observe feedback. Go to our Group Pointers for extra info and particulars on the right way to modify your e mail settings.