Braid: Setting Minister Guilbeault's insulting declare that he doesn't favour some provinces over others

Article content material

Was it a only a unhealthy dream, or did federal Setting Minister Steven Guilbeault actually make this absurd comment?

“How truthful wouldn’t it be for the remainder of the federation if we began carving out exceptions for provinces?”

Article content material

Guilbeault did say that. He was speaking about his refusal to alter the 2035 deadline for Alberta’s electrical energy grid to succeed in net-zero emissions.

Article content material

At any distance from the federal towers of zealotry, Canada appears to be nothing however exceptions for provinces. Exceptions are how we stumble and bumble alongside as a nation.

Exceptions are sometimes optimistic, most notably in Quebec and Ontario, or unfavorable in provinces much less politically necessary to the Liberals.

Guilbeault went on to say, relating to exceptions, “we didn’t do it for (carbon) pricing.

“We labored with all provinces to make sure that we had a good and equitable system when it got here to pricing, and we are going to do the identical for the clear electrical energy laws.”

That’s false. Quebec’s cap-and-trade pricing system — an exception granted by Ottawa — ensures that Quebecers pay much less.

This has been recognized for years. The Canadian Taxpayers Federation lately stated Ottawa “is forcing drivers in each different province and territory to pay 14 cents per litre of fuel in carbon taxes, whereas Quebecers pay 10 cents per litre.”

Article content material

Article content material

Atlantic provinces have simply began paying carbon tax after Ottawa rejected their pricing plans.

The New Brunswick authorities, particularly, is furious. It claims the provincial plan would have minimize emissions by 40 to 45 per cent under 2005 ranges by 2030. That may beat the federal goal by 20 years.

Quebec makes related claims for its doubtful carbon buying and selling scheme, however that’s Guilbeault’s house province. Exception accredited.

In refusing to budge on his goal date for electrical energy, Guilbeault is definitely making Alberta an exception — the unfavorable sort.

Greater than 60 per cent of Alberta’s electrical energy technology comes from pure fuel. Smith claims that transition to different sources by 2035, together with some use of “abated” pure fuel, merely isn’t potential with out extreme financial hurt.

Others disagree, together with the provincial NDP, which helps internet zero by 2035. Rachel Notley’s occasion wonders, as many others do, why the province put a hiatus on inexperienced vitality tasks.

However there’s little doubt that Alberta and Saskatchewan have very severe challenges in assembly internet zero by 2035.

Article content material

Guilbeault can get powerful as a result of most different provinces haven’t any drawback in any respect. They’re blessed with all these dams and rivers that produce hydroelectric energy. By luck of geography, they’re already many of the option to internet zero.

(The next figures could also be considerably dated as a result of provincial percentages are possible shifting by the month.)

Quebec has by far essentially the most hydroelectric energy. It accounts for 94 per cent of the provincial grid. Wind produces 5 per cent. Pure fuel and petroleum are hint quantities.

Ontario is 25 per cent powered by hydro. Fifty-one per cent is nuclear. Wind and pure fuel totalled about 10 per cent every.

For the Liberals’ key province, eliminating pure fuel in 12 years isn’t any drawback in any respect.

It’s just about the identical in B.C. (87 per cent hydro), Manitoba (97 per cent), and Newfoundland and Labrador (96 per cent).

Little Prince Edward Island, bless its coronary heart, is 99 per cent wind-powered.

New Brunswick has essentially the most various technology, with about 60 per cent nuclear and hydro. Thirty per cent comes from coal.

Nova Scotia is the one province with an issue as severe as Alberta and Saskatchewan. In recent times, 74 per cent of its energy has come from coal and pure fuel.

A goal delay of some years is cheap for Alberta, Saskatchewan and doubtless Nova Scotia. Different provinces would possible go alongside with out criticism, though we might count on some preaching from the Bloc Quebecois.

However Steven Guilbeault appears blind to something however his trigger. His discuss of treating provinces equally is each absurd and insulting.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau missed an opportunity to fireplace Guilbeault when he shuffled cupboard in July.

It’s by no means too late.

Don Braid’s column seems frequently within the Herald.

X: @DonBraid

Article content material