Braid: The UCP has made up its thoughts on pension. Now it needs to make up yours

Braid: The UCP has made up its thoughts on pension. Now it needs to make up yours

Get the newest from Don Braid, Calgary Herald straight to your inbox

Article content material

Rachel Notley could be NDP premier at the moment if the federal government had began its pension “engagement” earlier than the Could 29 election.

However the UCP performed down this fully-formed technique through the marketing campaign, saying it wasn’t an election subject in any respect.

Article content material

4 months later they’re spending greater than $10 million to stamp the pension within the public thoughts as an actual risk, and utilizing legendary numbers to do it.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Many views got here out in Monday’s first phone city corridor, however one from Doug in Fort McMurray stood out.

“If you happen to anticipate me to consider something from this present authorities, you understand what? I’ve acquired some stunning, stunning land that will probably be coming out there out by Fort Hills when Suncor is completed with it.”

He was the one caller in 90 minutes to be lower off by the moderator.

Doug had simply famous that Premier Danielle Smith stated “no” to the pension through the marketing campaign.

Earlier than the vote, Smith stated UCP aspirations just like the Alberta police power and the pension plan “are usually not in our marketing campaign as a result of I feel we’ve acquired so many issues that we’ve completed that we’re enthusiastic about. We’re bringing in $10-a-day daycare.”

She did say these points could possibly be revisited after the election. Now the pension scheme is a great distance past revisitation. It’s a full-bore gross sales job. And we haven’t heard far more about daycare.

Jim Dinning, the previous PC treasurer who’s main the engagement, carried out a fairly even-handed call-in. He thanked critics and promised to “mark down” the feedback for presidency to see. He stated the three panelists are usually not “advocates.”

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

However they have been prepared with loads of knowledge taken from the federal government’s report on pensions.

And there’s the issue, extremely seen on the pension drive web site.

Alberta pension plan Jim Dinning Danielle Smith Nate Horner
Premier Danielle Smith (proper), President of Treasury Board and Minister of Finance Nate Horner (left) and Jim Dinning, chair of the Alberta Pension Plan Report Engagement Panel launch an unbiased report on a possible Alberta Pension Plan on Sept. 21. Picture by Darren Makowichuk /Postmedia Community

This isn’t about engagement in any respect. The objective is to vary minds. That begins with the title: “What’s in it for you.”

The UCP guarantees larger pension funds, decrease premiums, even a $5,000 to $10,000 money bonus upon retirement.

That is based mostly on the premise that Alberta would understand $5 billion a 12 months in “financial savings,” whereas extracting a $334 billion fee from Ottawa upon withdrawing from the Canada Pension Plan (greater than half the nationwide fund).

These are essentially the most optimistic projections within the report. Decrease figures would imply much less flexibility in offering advantages or decrease premium funds.

Nowhere does the federal government point out the response from Canada Pension Plan Investments.

“The quantity the report says could possibly be extracted from the CPP is unattainable and based mostly on an invented method,” the company stated in a press release.

“Any thought of a withdrawal from the CPP could be advanced, fiercely disputed, contain poiltical posturing an would lead to danger for Albertans for years to return.”

Commercial 4

Article content material

That’s a strong warning that though the province has the technical proper to withdraw, Ottawa will dispute nearly any quantity claimed by Alberta.

In response to all that, the engagement panel mildly concedes that the small print may find yourself in court docket.

Associated Tales

Alberta’s wealthy entitlement, they are saying, outcomes from larger historic funds based mostly on “demographics” – a youthful, richer inhabitants.

The bigger motive is Alberta’s excessive good luck in internet hosting Canada’s main oil and fuel deposits. The remainder of Canada is aware of this and would bitterly oppose any critical effort to make off with the nationwide pension.

Commercial 5

Article content material

Meghan from Peace River informed the panel she has “deep issues in regards to the absolute lack of skepticism” across the numbers within the report.

By utilizing the identical method, she famous, Ontario may declare much more than Alberta.

“How would we be responding to this if it was the province of Ontario placing this ahead and saying they’re entitled to 85 per cent of this exact same fund?” she requested.

Many calls to the panel have been from individuals genuinely curious in regards to the pension thought. Others got here from advocates.

However the authorities has already made up it its thoughts. Now it has till 2025 – the tentative time for a referendum – to make up yours.

Don Braid’s column seems commonly within the Herald

X: @DonBraid

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a energetic however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We now have enabled e mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e mail for those who obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you observe or if a person you observe feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Pointers for extra info and particulars on the right way to regulate your e mail settings.

    Commercial 1