Braid: UCP pension drive is popping Alberta right into a nationwide pariah, even amongst conservatives

The troubled Trudeau Liberals see Alberta’s proposed withdrawal from the Canada Pension Plan as a risk they will rally almost everybody in opposition to

Get the most recent from Don Braid, Calgary Herald straight to your inbox

Article content material

The UCP are at all times completely satisfied to harass and problem Liberal Ottawa. Such enjoyable. However now they’re going too far, making Alberta appear like a risk to the entire nation.

Ontario desires a crash nationwide assembly of finance ministers to debate Alberta’s drive to withdraw from the Canada Pension Plan.

Article content material

“We imagine this proposal may trigger severe hurt over the long run to working individuals and retirees in Ontario and throughout Canada,” Ontario Finance Minister Peter Bethlenfalvy wrote to his federal counterpart, Chrystia Freeland.

Commercial 2

Article content material

As a basic rule, you don’t wish to unite your mates and your enemies. That’s what’s occurring with the UCP’s weird declare to greater than half the nationwide pension fund.

The Progressive Conservatives beneath Ontario Premier Doug Ford are usually pleasant to Alberta. Bethlenfalvy expressed admiration for the province and the vitality trade, at the same time as he known as for the assembly.

Ontario additionally mentioned it should launch a courtroom case in assist of Alberta’s current Supreme Courtroom victory over the Impression Evaluation Act.

However friendship dies with this pension drive. It’s political poison for Alberta.

The deeply troubled Trudeau Liberals see it as a risk they will rally almost everybody in opposition to. Even sympathetic conservative provinces are beginning to swing their very own golf equipment.

“Our authorities firmly helps the CPP and shares your severe (federal) considerations with Alberta’s proposal to withdraw,” Bethlenfalvy mentioned.

Premier Danielle Smith’s powerful stand pleases these Albertans who wish to sever ties with the nationwide system, from pensions to tax assortment, policing, employment insurance coverage and far else.

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

The entire controversy will thrill Take Again Alberta varieties who plan to flood the UCP annual basic assembly Nov. 3 and 4, hoping to take over the governing board of the celebration.

These of us are essential to Smith however they’re solely a fraction of Alberta opinion. The NDP mentioned about 30,000 individuals responded to its personal ballot, and 90 per cent had been against the pension drive.

The second phone city corridor “engagement” on Tuesday night introduced growing objections.

The panellists, led by former Treasurer Jim Dinning, say they’re goal, however don’t give that impression once they defend the UCP’s LifeWorks examine that claims Alberta may depart the CPP with a money fee of $334 billion.

Dinning likes to say LifeWorks did the one full examine, regardless that Alberta Treasury itself has produced a lot decrease estimates.

Jim Dinning
Former provincial treasurer Jim Dinning is chairman of the Alberta Pension Plan Report Engagement Panel. Photograph by Darren Makowichuk /Postmedia

U of C economics professor Trevor Tombe has additionally printed his personal detailed and rigorous work.

He discovered that Alberta could be entitled to solely $120 billion at a most.

Tombe concludes that annual contributions wouldn’t drop by $1,425 a 12 months, because the UCP suggests, however solely $400.

Commercial 4

Article content material

On the similar time, pension funds wouldn’t enhance by almost as a lot as the federal government implies. The entire arduous battle wouldn’t be well worth the effort.

Tombe additionally factors out that sooner or later, Ottawa would possibly say it has to switch the pension legislation to accommodate Alberta. This might require a nationwide referendum.

Altering a single clause would require assist from two-thirds of the provinces and two-thirds of the Canadian inhabitants.

That’s an much more tough customary than a constitutional modification, which wants approval from seven provinces with 50 per cent of the inhabitants.

Many individuals surprise how a lot Dinning is being paid to do that work. They’re entitled to ask, particularly when Preston Manning will get $253,000 to go up the federal government’s COVID response examine, technically known as the Public Well being Emergencies Assessment Panel.

Requested about Dinning’s compensation, Alberta Treasury says he’s paid customary charges for committee work. Treasury handed on orders-in-council courting again to 2009.

How they apply is murky, however it seems that essentially the most Dinning could be paid is $550 for an eight-hour day, and possibly much less.

Finance Minister Nate Horner can double this if he feels prefer it. Bills could be claimed.

That’s not peanuts for most individuals; however nonetheless, Dinning may be the very best deal Albertans get from this pension craziness.

It’s not a lot comfort.

Don Braid’s column seems repeatedly within the Herald.

X: @DonBraid

Associated Tales

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a full of life however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We’ve enabled e-mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e-mail in case you obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you observe or if a consumer you observe feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Tips for extra data and particulars on alter your e-mail settings.

    Commercial 1