Braid: With carbon tax in serious trouble, federal ministers are caught with Alberta's purple herring

Braid: With carbon tax in serious trouble, federal ministers are caught with Alberta's purple herring

The UCP instantly has their strongest case ever towards the carbon tax, however lust for a provincial pension plan will get in the best way

Get the most recent from Don Braid, Calgary Herald straight to your inbox

Article content material

The UCP instantly has their strongest case ever towards the carbon tax, however lust for a provincial pension plan will get in the best way.

Provincial and federal finance ministers will meet nearly on Friday after an pressing demand from Ontario.

Article content material

Sadly, it’s all about nationwide hostility to the UCP’s pension dream, which the federal government continues to advertise with unrealistic numbers and not possible guarantees.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Finance Minister Nate Horner despatched a letter to federal Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland Wednesday, repeating the LifeWorks examine conclusion that Alberta may very well be owed $334 billion from the Canada Pension Plan.

He additionally acknowledged that Ottawa might need different info. You’ll be able to depend on that.

This can be a large wasted alternative. The assembly needs to be all in regards to the carbon tax uproar.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau made a generational political blunder when he personally exempted heating oil from the carbon tax as a throw to stress from Atlantic Liberal ministers and MPs.

That’s not a idea. Rural Growth Minister Gudie Hutchings admitted it publicly. Simply elect extra Liberals on the Prairies, she mentioned, and perhaps you’ll get a break too.

The Liberals then doubled down towards calls for for comparable breaks. No extra carve-outs, they mentioned categorically.

Saskatchewan premier Scott Moe blew up. Except pure fuel for heating will get an identical break in Saskatchewan, he’ll inform SaskEnergy to cease amassing and remitting the carbon tax on Jan. 1.

Premier Danielle Smith would like to make the identical level. However Alberta has no Crown company to distribute pure fuel. She will’t give such an order to personal firms.

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

Associated Tales

The feds instantly attacked Moe, saying refusal to gather the tax can be towards the legislation.

It’s the top of hypocrisy for federal ministers to accuse Moe of breaking the legislation, after they simply lifted the tax for one class of gasoline.

They could not technically violate their very own laws, however they actually shatter its spirit and credibility.

The condemnation is sort of unanimous from everywhere in the local weather spectrum.

Columnist Max Fawcett wrote within the on-line publication Nationwide Observer, which focuses on local weather advocacy: “They’ve even managed the herculean textual content of creating me agree with Alberta Premier Danielle Smith.”

Commercial 4

Article content material

Smith had mentioned on X, previously Twitter, “The federal authorities has determined that one a part of Canada with one kind of residence heating is worthy of a carbon tax break, whereas these residing elsewhere utilizing one other kind of residence heating don’t.”

Fawcett’s got here to a startling conclusion for such a agency advocate. “The carbon tax and rebate — which so many environmental economists have spent a lot effort and time defending — is successfully lifeless.”

Within the legislature Tuesday, UCP MLAs debated a authorities movement to kill your entire shopper carbon tax.

A number of argued that Ottawa at all times offered that tax as an ethical obligation to behave towards local weather change.

Premier Danielle Smith following the Speech from the Throne
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith following the Speech from the Throne on the Alberta Legislature in Edmonton on Monday Oct. 30, 2023. David Bloom/Postmedia

Peace River MLA Dan Williams mentioned: “The reality is that from the very begin it was not in regards to the ethical argument. That condescension, that dripping ethical indignation was all a sham. Its objective was nothing greater than to realize energy and to realize your tax {dollars} on the expense of belief in our establishments.”

Twenty-six NDP members sat silent for all this. They voted towards the UCP movement with out debating it.

However Chief Rachel Notley had supplied her personal movement for Ottawa to remove the carbon tax on all heating fuels for the interval of the Atlantic tax reduction (three years).

Commercial 5

Article content material

The NDP wasn’t prepared to ask for abolition of your entire tax. Nevertheless it was exceptional that they urged any reduction in any respect, after creating their very own carbon tax when in workplace, after which accepting the federal alternative.

That was only one signal of collapsing assist for the tax. Some First Nations demand a full exemption. The NDP B.C., which has its personal federally-approved carbon regime, faces calls to exempt all residence heating gasoline.

Trudeau has created a monstrous mess that threatens each the tax regime and his management.

And what’s going to Canada’s finance ministers speak about Friday? An enormous purple herring from Alberta.

Don Braid’s column seems usually within the Herald

X: @DonBraid

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a vigorous however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback might take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We’ve got enabled electronic mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an electronic mail in case you obtain a reply to your remark, there’s an replace to a remark thread you comply with or if a consumer you comply with feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Tips for extra info and particulars on the way to regulate your electronic mail settings.

    Commercial 1