Calgary's workplace conversion program is on pause. What's subsequent?

As town seems to combine its new housing plan into the workplace conversion program, builders say main public funding could be wanted for conversions to turn into viable non-market housing

Article content material

Calgary’s high-profile effort to transform empty workplaces blew by a significant milestone not too long ago when town paused this system after maxing out its funding.

However this system is way from full as town waits for builders to complete building and it strikes to advocate for funding that may enable functions to reopen, leaving a number of questions on the place town goes subsequent.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Article content material

The town can even must flush out amendments for this system to suit with its newly adopted housing technique, one of many causes cited for pausing this system. Metropolis administration stated the brand new phrases will give attention to market, non-market, inexpensive, inclusive and pupil housing.

The town expects to see its first office-to-residential conversion open later this fall when 112 models at The Cornerstone, a challenge by PeopleFirst Developments on fifth Avenue S.W., are scheduled to open.

And whereas town awaits 16 extra tasks to come back to fruition — three which haven’t been publicly introduced, whereas 4 stay beneath overview — Ward 8 Coun. Courtney Walcott stated this system bears sufficient success for town to get again to the desk with the federal and provincial governments to request extra funding.

“The proof is already there, the success is already laid out,” stated the councillor, who represents a big portion of downtown. “We simply need to know if (the federal authorities) needs in on serving to to heal the downtown.”

The Alberta area managing director at CBRE argued in an interview final week that town may select to renew this system when extra conversions go to market.

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

“Well, I believe they’re holding off … they’re simply saying, ‘Look, are you going to go forward or not?” stated Greg Kwong.

Calgary metropolis council shall be reviewing $50 million in potential program bridge funding at this November’s funds deliberations, town informed Postmedia on Monday. The funding was really helpful by town’s Housing and Affordability Activity Pressure.

Cornerstone office residential conversion
Pictured is The Cornerstone, situated at 909 5 Avenue S.W. in downtown Calgary on Tuesday, February 28, 2023. The Cornerstone is among the workplace buildings which is being transformed right into a residential complicated. Azin Ghaffari/Postmedia file

‘The maths doesn’t math except you get public help’

The town stated final Wednesday will probably be adjusting this system’s phrases of reference to align it with its new housing technique, a seven-year roadmap to extend market and non-market housing provide. The plan goals to create 1,000 market properties and three,000 non-market properties yearly.

Walcott and Ward 7 Coun. Terry Wong each stated it’s too early to say what changes shall be made to the phrases.

It’s unlikely builders will pursue conversions on their very own because of the sheer price related to such tasks with out authorities help, stated Ray Wong, vice-president of information options at AltusGroup, a industrial actual property companies and software program firm.

“Until the developer (finds) it is sensible on the professional forma — except they’ve these subsidies or incentives — it’s onerous for it to make sense.”

Commercial 4

Article content material

And incentivizing builders to supply non-market housing by conversions shall be a problem, he stated.

One of many metropolis’s first-ever accomplished conversions, a 95,000 square-foot former workplace acquired by HomeSpace Society in 2021, created 82 rooms of non-market housing and 10 emergency shelter models.

The town authorised $5.5 million in funding for the roughly $30-million challenge. HomeSpace additionally acquired $16.6 million from the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. (CMHC) by its Fast Housing Initiative and $2 million from the province. The society fundraised the rest of the funds.

As a non-market housing supplier, its rents cowl the society’s primary prices. For it to pursue extra tasks like a conversion, it wants each greenback to come back by public our bodies and thru fundraising, stated Emily Campbell, a spokeswoman for HomeSpace.

“The maths is completely different for us than it’s for market builders … As a result of we’re charging such low lease, we truly must get a few of these capital prices coated,” she stated.

“The maths doesn’t math except you get public help.”

Commercial 5

Article content material

HomeSpace’s rents are 37 per cent under market fee, Campbell stated. That may imply renters pay about $1,089 monthly for a one-bedroom condominium. (The typical one-bedroom lease in Calgary for September was $1,730, in response to

As soon as paid for, building was its personal problem. Workplace buildings characteristic flooring plates usually inappropriate for regular condominium layouts, which implies some bedrooms are windowless.

The identical goes for builders present process conversions for at-market residences. On the historic Barron Constructing on eighth Avenue S.W., which is being redeveloped by Strategic Group, builders have been pressured to construct round heritage components — and work with out drawings of the constructing, which have been by no means created for the 73-year-old skyscraper.

Staff have additionally encountered deterioration and structural issues. Strategic Group anticipated these points when it determined to pursue the conversion, stated Ken Toews, its senior vice-president of growth. The town has contributed $8.5 million to the challenge that can create 118 properties. Like HomeSpace, it isn’t being funded beneath town’s conversion incentive program.

Commercial 6

Article content material

Toews stated the challenge will price about $50 per sq. foot greater than a typical conversion.

“It’s in all probability one of the difficult tasks of my profession … That is the challenge that I’ll be speaking about 30 years from now,” he stated of the Barron Constructing, which he added shall be a significant “legacy asset” for Strategic Group. Strategic has its personal building firm, making it simpler to adapt to surprising issues.

Builders are additionally contending with unruly provide chains and change-work orders, stated Wong of AltusGroup.

“You’re nonetheless a few of these prices which can be tough to manage … the federal government can’t regulate labour prices or building prices, to a sure extent, with out taxes,” Wong stated.

Barron Building office to residential conversion
Artist rendering of the conversion of downtown Calgary’s Barron Constructing. Opening in 2024, the Barron Constructing shall be reworked from a heritage workplace tower into a contemporary, vibrant residential neighborhood. Courtesy Strategic Group

‘Success is the problem right here’

The town’s investments within the ongoing conversions have nonetheless been vital.

Among the many 10 publicly authorised tasks, the Palliser One constructing on ninth Avenue S.E. subsequent to Calgary Tower is receiving essentially the most funding from town at $15 million. The conversion will open 176 models, breaking right down to an funding of $85,000 per unit. Owned by Aspen Properties, the corporate says it expects to finish the conversion by early subsequent yr.

Commercial 7

Article content material

Between the 17 conversions, town says there can have been $4 of personal funding for each $1 of public funding.

It’s unclear whether or not the conversions will launch sufficient new housing to decrease rents in Calgary, which have elevated 13.2 per cent since final September, Wong stated. Collectively, the 17 tasks would create about 2,300 properties in Calgary, in response to town.

“We’re not going to see all that new provide hit {the marketplace} without delay,” Wong stated.

In the meantime, a brand new report by Avison Younger confirmed Calgary’s downtown workplace emptiness fee hit 27.2 per cent within the third quarter, down 0.1 proportion level because the earlier quarter.

At this juncture, Calgary nonetheless stays a distance from its focused quantity of eradicated workplace house: As soon as the remaining tasks are accomplished, it would have eliminated roughly 2.3 million sq. ft of workplace house from downtown. It’s aiming to take away six million sq. ft from downtown by 2031.

“To place it bluntly, success is the problem right here,” stated Walcott.

“We created this program with out full readability of what it could turn into, and … we’ve simply been discovering out an increasing number of that it’s one thing that each the market needs and public wants.”

[email protected]

X: @mattscace67

Office conversion

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a vigorous however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback might take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the location. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We’ve enabled e-mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e-mail should you obtain a reply to your remark, there’s an replace to a remark thread you comply with or if a consumer you comply with feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Tips for extra info and particulars on the best way to alter your e-mail settings.

    Commercial 1