Opinion: Banff park plan for prepare from Calgary is transformative

Article content material

Banff Nationwide Park is not any stranger to vary, each radical and incremental.

The 1911 resolution to permit automobiles into the park modified who visited it and the way. Snowboarding within the Nineteen Sixties reworked it right into a year-round neighborhood and a city was born. The 1988 adoption of ecological integrity slowed growth whereas Canmore ballooned. The 1996 Banff Bow Valley Research referred to as for change, however little has been executed. Visitation continues to develop as do arguments about what must be executed to repair this as soon as and for all.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Article content material

Submit-pandemic predictions of a gradual customer return have been met with record-breaking numbers. About 90 per cent of that’s by private car and recurrently exceeds the city’s threshold in peak intervals. Training-based mitigation methods have had little impact. Analysis means that many individuals don’t thoughts crowds and should even desire it.

What to do? Banff is a nationwide treasure that evokes all kinds of visitation. It may be simple to label a lot of it as over-tourism (a ineffective time period) however we additionally know that lives are reworked by these visits. Many residents got here for a go to and stayed.

Regardless, limiting visitation is negated by the freeway and restricted controls over entry. The addition of bus shuttles to and across the park are optimistic however they’ve restricted capability. A 2019 examine reported that residents and guests need daring, long-term options.

These options start with a multimodal transportation system that features passenger rail and regional shuttles to iconic websites. This can restore structural management of the entrance nation and, particularly, day visitation again to Parks Canada and the city. Training and coverage efforts haven’t been efficient for Banff, nor have they labored for Barcelona, Venice, Yellowstone and others. Lengthy-term change requires a structural spine.

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

The online-zero hydrogen-powered prepare will accommodate 11 million riders yearly, largely labour mobility and commuting. About 20 per cent will make their method to Banff and take away 4.5 million Bow Valley-directed automotive journeys and cut back Banff’s outsized GHG emissions. The majority of ridership shall be between YYC and downtown Calgary. Animal mortality is all the time a priority, however it’s understood inside environmental circles that the majority of it is because of grain automobiles, not passenger rail. The Banff Railways Lands growth will act because the transportation hub and help customer dispersal by reducing Bow River bridge site visitors and drawing guests to the outskirts of city.

Parks Canada’s administration plan (2022) made encouraging inexperienced mass transit and discouraging fossil-fuel private autos official coverage. Its Knowledgeable Panel on Transferring Folks Sustainably within the Bow Valley recognized a mass transit prepare between Calgary and Banff as a transformative answer to lowering the environmental affect of private autos on the park.

What does this imply? Residents and longtime guests will expertise Banff a bit otherwise. Some guests might not return if unimpeded private car use is curtailed. Over time, these amenable to mass transit will go to Banff and others will go elsewhere. All of the whereas, Journey Alberta is intent on rising tourism in the remainder of the province. There has by no means been a greater time to embark on daring measures to supply Banff with a sustainable future.

Commercial 4

Article content material

A resident-first strategy to sustainable tourism means infrastructure ought to help guests and residents — a prepare does that, whereas the just lately proposed underground customer parking doesn’t. It does nothing to help the atmosphere, neither is it a long-term answer.

Managing the park is a big problem however it’s time to contemplate daring measures that respect its mandate whereas positioning it for the long run. Banff is not any stranger to vary, each radical and incremental.

The irony is that multimodal transport to reinforce long-term sustainability will not be even that radical.

Joe Pavelka, PhD, is a professor at Mount Royal College.

Article content material