Too good to fail, too dangerous to win: The lengthy and quick story of the Calgary Flames

Article content material

Heading into Monday’s motion with a latest 4-2 loss to the New Jersey Devils, the Flames file over their earlier 10 video games fell to 5-5-0. At residence this yr, the staff is 6-6-1. They’re presently firmly ensconced in the course of a season-defining stretch of video games going through most of the NHL’s finest groups. Their efforts throughout this difficult check have yielded 4 wins and 4 losses.

Article content material

Virtually any quantity you care to reference tends to put the membership firmly within the fiftieth percentile or beneath within the league. Their .463 win share is nice for twenty third total. Their -15 objective differential is twenty fifth. Their 78 objectives scored is nice for twenty second finest.

Article content material

Nonetheless, whereas Calgary has already fallen effectively behind the category of the Western Convention, they continue to be only a handful of factors outdoors of the ultimate Wild Card spot. And, maybe as critically, they’re seven factors forward of the San Jose Sharks, the odds-on favourites to win the draft lottery to pick future star Macklin Celebrini first total in June 2024. The Flames are sadly suspended between being nice and awful, touchdown nearly equidistant within the standings between selecting high three within the draft and being assured residence ice within the post-season.

In different phrases, no man’s land.

It isn’t essentially a nasty factor to be a member of the NHL’s center class, however in Calgary’s case, the conundrum going through new GM Craig Conroy is a professional head-scratcher. Brad Treliving’s dangerous gambit of changing Johnny Gaudreau and Matthew Tkachuk on the fly in the summertime of 2022 was an effort to wrench again open a rivalry window that had out of the blue snapped shut. When the membership’s two cornerstone stars fled at no cost company and demanded a commerce, the group discovered itself balanced unexpectedly on the precipice of a rebuild.

Article content material

Article content material

As a substitute of plunging ahead, Treliving scrambled away from the sting by transplanting two new name-brand veterans into the staff’s core in Nazem Kadri and Jonathan Huberdeau. It was a determined, unprecedented experiment. One which has not paid off.

Treliving is gone and Conroy is left with a staff misplaced in purgatory. It isn’t simply that the membership is mediocre presently, it’s that there isn’t a apparent path again to contendership. The vast majority of long-term contracts on the group’s cap are owned by gamers extra prone to worsen somewhat than to get higher. Mainstays Elias Lindholm, Noah Hanifin and Chris Tanev are pending free brokers and would require raises to stay in Calgary (in the event that they decide to remain). Andrew Mangiapane and Yegor Sharangovich can flee for greener pastures in the summertime of 2025. None of those gamers are superstars, to make certain, however they’re members of what’s the core of the staff presently.

That leaves the brand new regime within the uncomfortable place of getting to spend extra simply to maintain the present band collectively, or to start cashing in commerce property earlier than they flee. There may be the pure temptation to do each, to aim to string the needle by re-signing some gamers whereas buying and selling others.

Article content material

It’s implausible that the Flames will be capable of successfully serve the dual, opposing masters of rebuilding and competitiveness concurrently, nevertheless. Within the hypothetical future the place Conroy grants a increase to Hanifin and Lindholm, however trades Tanev and Mangiapane, the more than likely final result is a barely worse, barely costlier roster.

That is the insidious nature of the mediocrity entice. When a staff is simply adequate to at all times be inside proximity of the playoffs, the siren tune of incremental enhancements is ever-present. Only one extra huge save, only a few extra bounces, only a couple extra OT wins.

Organizations in Calgary’s place are continuously battling the attrition endemic to the NHL, that means these tantalizing marginal enhancements both fail to maneuver the needle or by no means arrive as their gamers age out of their primes, demand raises, or depart as free brokers. The psychological entice of “at all times in however by no means shut” inevitably offers option to a sensible one, the place the GM is pressured to take a position increasingly more cap area and future property simply to run in place. The severity of the inexorable rebuild is finally decided by the depth of this deficit spending — a actuality that may have to be acknowledged in the end by a franchise that considers scorched earth teardowns to be anathema.

The Jarome Iginla period gave option to the Gaudreau period. The Tkachuk period ended earlier than it started. And we’re now pensively discovering that the Huberdeau period just isn’t actual — simply an phantasm conjured as a ultimate, parting trick on the best way out of city.

Craig Conroy finds himself at a crossroads, a kind of undifferentiated liminal area between eras. Will the seek for a brand new era-defining expertise start in earnest, or will the Calgary Flames proceed to fall prey to the curse of indefinite mediocrity?

Particular to the Solar

Particular to the Herald

Article content material