Varcoe: Feuding nonetheless trumps fixing in vitality turf warfare, even after pivotal prime court docket ruling

Because the previous week has proven, co-operation doesn’t appear potential

Get the most recent from Chris Varcoe, Calgary Herald straight to your inbox

Article content material

When the Supreme Courtroom of Canada dominated that the Trudeau authorities’s Affect Evaluation Act was largely unconstitutional, it additionally talked about the necessity for federal and provincial governments to train their powers “within the spirit of co-operative federalism.”

A lot for that noble thought.

Article content material

Because the previous week has proven, co-operation doesn’t appear potential.

For the reason that pivotal authorized determination final week, either side have talked about eager to work collectively. Heck, a joint provincial-federal working group with senior civil servants even met on Wednesday.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Then, political actuality strikes and either side reveal what they’re actually considering. It’s not about working hand-in-hand, until brass knuckles are concerned.

For instance, federal Setting Minister Steven Guilbeault was requested by reporters Tuesday concerning the incoming oilpatch emissions cap within the wake of the highest court docket’s determination, in addition to the looks of Suncor Vitality CEO Wealthy Kruger at a parliamentary committee this week.

Kruger had been requested to point out up on the committee to clarify his remarks from August concerning the oil firm’s “disproportionate emphasis on the longer-term vitality transition.” These feedback led Guilbeault to blast the CEO through the summer season, saying it strengthened the necessity for a federal emissions cap on Canada’s oil and fuel business.

In Ottawa this week, Kruger reiterated Suncor’s dedication to being a part of the Pathways Alliance oilsands group and dealing collectively to succeed in net-zero emissions by 2050.

Apparently, that didn’t change the surroundings minister’s thoughts.

“No, by no means,” Guilbeault informed reporters in Ottawa.

“If something, he’s doubling down on the truth that a big oil firm like his ought to ignore a problem like local weather change and, to me, that’s unacceptable.”

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

Ignoring the very fact Kruger stated nothing about brushing apart local weather considerations, the CEO additionally confronted flack for saying he hadn’t learn the brand new federal clear gasoline laws in depth.

“It reinforces the truth that we as a federal authorities, we want to ensure the oil and fuel sector does its fair proportion on the subject of preventing local weather change,” Guilbeault added.

Suncor CEO Rich Kruger
CEO and president of Suncor Vitality Wealthy Kruger was photographed on the Suncor workplace constructing in downtown Calgary on Tuesday, Could 9, 2023. Azin Ghaffari/Postmedia

The sector stays the biggest emitting business in Canada, accountable for 28 per cent of all greenhouse fuel emissions in 2021. It has additionally been decreasing emissions per barrel, which have dropped by 23 per cent since 2009, a report by S&P International Commodity Insights just lately discovered, whereas many firms have adopted a net-zero goal.

New federal insurance policies, together with the nationwide value on carbon and clear gasoline laws, are in place, whereas draft laws on the emissions restrict for the sector are coming this fall.

Now, you may assume the federal authorities’s plans for an emissions cap may decelerate after the Supreme Courtroom’s ruling on the Affect Evaluation Act. The highest court docket sided with Alberta and located elements of the act unconstitutional, veering into areas of provincial authority.

Commercial 4

Article content material

But, Guilbeault and Pure Sources Minister Jonathan Wilkinson indicated the federal government is continuing with the emissions cap.

“I don’t see the ruling as being an issue for the federal government transferring ahead,” Wilkinson informed reporters.

“Clearly, we wish to work with the provinces and territories to make sure that we’re truly doing these items in as collaborative a means as we are able to. However on the finish of the day, the federal authorities has a duty to guard the surroundings.”

On the provincial facet, Premier Danielle Smith, who has beforehand raised the opportunity of utilizing her sovereignty act to combat the emissions restrict and federal Clear Electrical energy Rules (CER), responded by blasting the federal surroundings minister, but once more.

“I’d say that Setting Minister Steven Guilbeault is an ideologue. He’s at all times been an ideologue. He’s at all times been going off saying issues unilaterally,” Smith stated Wednesday.

“I simply take him much less and fewer severely as a result of, fairly frankly, they misplaced on the Supreme Courtroom. The Supreme Courtroom stated they must make it possible for they proceed in a spirit of co-operative federalism.”

Commercial 5

Article content material

Associated Tales

This feud is unfolding whereas the province has launched an aggressive $8-million promoting marketing campaign in opposition to the federal authorities’s CER, warning it might result in blackouts and big will increase in electrical energy payments.

So the place is the spirit of co-operation?

In final week’s court docket determination, Supreme Courtroom Chief Justice Richard Wagner wrote within the 5-2 majority determination that there’s little doubt Parliament can go impression evaluation laws to reduce the dangers that some main tasks might pose to the surroundings.

Commercial 6

Article content material

However the act overstepped the mark, he wrote.

“It stays open to Parliament to design environmental laws, as long as it respects the division of powers. Furthermore, it’s open to Parliament and the provincial legislatures to train their respective powers over the surroundings harmoniously, within the spirit of co-operative federalism.”

College of Alberta regulation professor Eric Adams stated the concept of co-operative federalism is regularly raised by the highest court docket in issues the place each ranges of presidency have a job to play.

“The upshot of that’s we’re going to must reside in a world during which each governments are exercising jurisdiction over comparable areas or matters, and that co-operation can be higher than competitors,” he stated Thursday.

But, there’s additionally a political actuality.

Either side appear to view compromise as the opposite facet giving in.

With the announcement of billions of {dollars} in proposed decarbonization tasks nonetheless within the air — equivalent to Dow’s huge net-zero carbon emissions ethylene cracker and derivatives complicated in Alberta — either side have to type out these points or danger shedding much-needed funding.

“It doesn’t look good whenever you look on social media, however that’s often not the entire story,” stated former provincial vitality and surroundings minister Sonya Savage, who’s now senior counsel with regulation agency Borden Ladner Gervais.

“I believe there’s quite a lot of collaboration nonetheless occurring behind the scenes . . . It’s too necessary to not discover a path ahead.”

Chris Varcoe is a Calgary Herald columnist.

[email protected]

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a vigorous however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the location. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We’ve enabled electronic mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an electronic mail when you obtain a reply to your remark, there’s an replace to a remark thread you comply with or if a person you comply with feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Pointers for extra data and particulars on find out how to regulate your electronic mail settings.

    Commercial 1