Opinion: Chamber ought to cease pushing for residential tax improve

Article content material

Calgary’s economic system has been by means of lots over the previous decade. From a recession and a pandemic to excessive inflation, each companies and households have felt the pinch financially.

With that in thoughts, it’s disappointing that Deborah Yedlin and the Calgary Chamber of Commerce are persevering with to push for households to pay extra in taxes. They proceed to do that by lobbying metropolis corridor to gather a bigger portion of its revenues from owners and a smaller portion from companies. 

Article content material

Article content material

There’s a higher method.

Think about if town decreased inefficient spending as a substitute of elevating taxes. That might assist each companies and the individuals who store of their shops — on a regular basis Calgarians.

Understandably, the chamber desires to ease the tax burden its members are paying — metropolis corridor’s tax will increase have been extreme. Many readers will bear in mind how companies across the metropolis started disclosing the big tax will increase they confronted a couple of years in the past. The previous German restaurant Wurst famous on its giant outside signal that its 2014 property taxes had been “$74k” and rose to “$208k” in 2019. It has since gone out of enterprise.

At metropolis corridor, we discover a very totally different scene. Regardless of claims by town that it has tightened its belt, whole expenditures have elevated 20 per cent since 2015. Life has remained snug there whereas these outdoors of presidency circles have struggled.

Observe that in 2018, three years after Calgary’s economic system went right into a recession, town’s administration was spending almost $8 million annually on retirement bonuses for workers — bonuses that had been fully indifferent from efficiency. You possibly can actually be the worst-performing worker within the metropolis authorities however nonetheless obtain a big handout on the best way out the door.

Article content material

Article content material

This anecdote is vital for 2 causes.

First, it’s council’s job to look below each stone for financial savings. Clearly, that wasn’t occurring as it took a 3rd occasion to show this drawback (I uncovered this concern whereas working for the Canadian Taxpayers Federation).

Second, council can’t depend on metropolis administration to convey ahead cheap concepts on learn how to cut back spending on compensation for metropolis employees — they face an apparent battle of curiosity.

Readers ought to take into account one other compensation concern that continues to burn quietly at metropolis corridor: pension prices.

Exterior of presidency, lower than one in 4 staff has a office pension. However on the Metropolis of Calgary, not solely do the overwhelming majority of staff obtain a pension, almost two thousand metropolis staff may also obtain a beneficiant top-up pension once they retire. In truth, greater than 200 metropolis staff will obtain three metropolis pensions once they retire. Should be good. 

SecondStreet.org analysis exhibits town spent extra on top-up pensions ($10.9 million) for its employees in 2018 than Edmonton, Montreal, Toronto, Ottawa, Mississauga, Brampton, Halifax, Vancouver, Winnipeg and Saskatoon mixed. Sure, mixed.

Article content material

The essential pension plan that the majority metropolis staff obtain, the Native Authorities Pension Plan, can be fairly beneficiant. It value town $76 million in 2009, however by 2019, the annual value for this pension had ballooned to $137 million. Why hasn’t council tackled this drawback, contemplating it has ballooned a lot? Maybe councillors are involved that doing so would draw extra consideration to their very own golden pensions?

Whereas many non-public sector staff have taken not less than one pay discount over the previous decade, metropolis knowledge exhibits there has by no means been a pay discount for its primary bargaining models over the previous 49 years. 

The best option to tackle these points could be for town to section in decrease, extra cheap compensation packages for brand new employees.

Hopefully, the chamber can see there are many alternatives for financial savings. The individuals who store at Calgary companies and dine in native eating places can’t afford to pay extra to metropolis corridor.

Colin Craig is the president of SecondStreet.org, a Calgary-based, Conservative-leaning think-tank.

Article content material