Yedlin: Clear Power Rules would carry big penalties for Alberta

Yedlin: Clear Power Rules would carry big penalties for Alberta

Article content material

As a rustic replete with regional variations, Canada has achieved a outstanding job over its greater than 150 years to stability the wants and distinctive traits of its geography, local weather variances and inhabitants. Whereas it won’t be good, methods resembling well being switch funds, equalization, and the latest child-care agreements are in place to serve and help all Canadians, regardless of the place they stay or the place they arrive from.

Commercial 2

Article content material

However sustaining this stability inside a federation requires powerful conversations — and difficult conversations have to be had concerning the proposed Clear Electrical energy Rules.

Article content material

Whereas Alberta is broadly aligned with the federal authorities’s dedication to decreasing emissions and the position low-carbon electrical energy will play in attaining this goal for the advantage of all Canadians, the CER as presently drafted can have profound financial and social penalties in Alberta.

Not solely will the rules have an effect on the reliability and stability of the grid, it’ll additionally trigger electrical energy costs to rise, trigger hardship for householders and render the province uncompetitive for funding, together with people who advance the event of decarbonizing applied sciences.

Clearly lacking within the federal authorities’s calculus is the actual fact Alberta is the one unregulated electrical energy market within the nation. Not like each different province and territory in Canada, our electrical system — from era to distribution — depends upon attracting non-public capital.

It’s one of many causes Alberta has been a magnet for renewable energy funding. Since 2019, $4.7 billion has been invested in renewable energy era — with the province boasting the most important photo voltaic farm within the nation.

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

But, even with the power of the renewable sector, it’s not enough to switch the necessity for energy generated by fossil fuels. And it’d by no means be — except and till there are dramatic advances in battery applied sciences and nuclear is seen as a viable possibility.

In his lately printed ebook, Between Doom & Denial, College of Alberta economics and legislation professor Andrew Leach succinctly presents the problem: “Our electrical energy grid must be balanced at each cut-off date, which signifies that electrical energy consumed at every on the spot must be concurrently generated in an influence plant or discharged from a battery. Neither wind nor photo voltaic will be reliably dispatched when wanted. Essential as they’re within the push towards a cleaner electrical energy grid, we want to ensure we don’t ignore the shortcomings.”

That is the basic drawback with the CER. The federal authorities made a flawed assumption {that a} blanket coverage would work — as a result of it’s simpler and eliminates the potential for favouring one province or one other.

Besides that it has.  

Final week’s announcement by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to droop the carbon tax on residence heating oil — which has an outsized profit to Atlantic Canada — has successfully blown up the one-size-fits-all strategy articulated within the CER. 

Commercial 4

Article content material

Now, there is no such thing as a method the federal authorities can ignore the considerations of both Alberta or Saskatchewan. The identical rationale for the carveout to enhance the affordability of residence heating oil can simply be made for the impact of the CER in Alberta on electrical energy costs.

What do they should contemplate?

The Calgary Chamber of Commerce, after intensive session with members, has a number of recommendations.

First, the 2035 timeline shouldn’t be possible. Anticipating each province to decarbonize on the identical fee — regardless of utterly completely different geographies — doesn’t make sense. It’s like treating all of your kids the identical — regardless of all of them being very completely different — so that folks can’t be accused of enjoying favourites.

Second, acknowledge the long-cycle nature of investments which were made and what which means within the context of the helpful lifetime of the amenities. When that point horizon is artificially shortened — which is successfully what the CER contemplates within the context of Alberta’s pure gas-fired peaking crops — the anticipated fee of return is compromised. This issues for 2 causes: one, as a result of Alberta’s market is deregulated, and buyers — not Crown companies — cope with the related lack of worth. Second, pure gas-fired peaking crops are important to long-term grid reliability, as per Leach’s feedback.

Commercial 5

Article content material

So, the timelines for compliance presently proposed — whether or not for peaking crops or different producing amenities — have to be prolonged. Opting to not, whereas accelerating time frames for retirement, distorts the marketplace for funding. 

Third, enhance the seize effectivity for abatement applied sciences past the proposed 30 tonnes per gigawatt-hour. This may enable flexibility to accommodate inevitable operational fluctuations that can happen as know-how continues to advance, in addition to assist unlock extra funding wanted to speed up innovation and derisk decarbonizing applied sciences. 

Fourth, amend the definition relating to what constitutes emergency circumstances. The enforcement of the CER falls beneath the Canadian Environmental Safety Act, which creates ambiguities associated to legal liabilities. This, in flip, may trigger companies to refuse or delay actions wanted to guard grid stability due to considerations relating to potential penalties. Neither consequence is suitable. 

The opposite problem is who or what determines an emergency. This could fall beneath the purview of the provincial or territorial system operators — permitting a fast response ought to there be any unexpected calls for on the grid, such because the scenario final December in Alberta.

Commercial 6

Article content material

Different points that benefit being amended embody eliminating the labour prescriptions related to the flexibility to entry Funding Tax Credit (ITCs). We want each unit of labour — to limit the eligible provide means to introduce a component of wage inflation as everybody bids on the final unit of labour. Moreover, instruments resembling carbon contracts for distinction are vital for each attracting and derisking investments, in addition to supporting funding in carbon seize utilization and storage.

Lastly, the CER must be aggressive with the prevailing U.S. rules and align with the Clear Air Act Requirements and Tips for Electrical Utilities. Doing so signifies that slightly than see funding {dollars} stream south, we will maximize the competitiveness of the electrical energy sector — making certain affordability, reliability and sustainability of our grid.

None of that is not possible. What it requires is a willingness by the federal authorities to acknowledge that each one electrical energy markets and grids usually are not created equal, and to make the mandatory changes reflecting these variations.

In asserting the modifications on residence heating, the federal authorities successfully opened Pandora’s field, setting a obtrusive precedent for adjusting a coverage to swimsuit a jurisdiction.

The identical should now occur for Alberta within the context of the CER. The clock is ticking.

Deborah Yedlin is the president and CEO of the Calgary Chamber of Commerce.

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a full of life however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. Now we have enabled electronic mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an electronic mail in case you obtain a reply to your remark, there’s an replace to a remark thread you observe or if a consumer you observe feedback. Go to our Group Tips for extra data and particulars on the right way to regulate your electronic mail settings.

    Commercial 1